Movements can often be sparked by the most inane and ordinary of circumstances.
In the case of abolition, one could argue that it all began with an insurance fraud case.
On November 29, 1781, the Zong, a slave ship carrying Africans to Jamaica, had a problem. Two months before, in their zeal for profits, the crew of the Zong stuffed the hold of the ship with more Africans than it could carry. By November, malnutrition and disease had taken the lives of seven crew members and almost 60 enslaved Africans.
Luke Collingwood, captain of the Zong, now made what he considered the best decision to stem the losses for his bosses in Liverpool. If he continued sailing, and delivered a pile of corpses to the Kingston docks, the owners had no redress. If, however, the sick Africans were lost at sea, then the shipowners’ insurance would cover the loss. Under the “jettison” clause, enslaved persons were considered cargo, and their loss would be covered at £30 per head.
So on November 29, Collingwood did the “logical” thing: he ordered 54 sick Africans dumped overboard. Another 42 perished the next day, and 26 the day after that. 10 Africans voluntarily flung themselves overboard, in an act of defiance against the captain’s decision. In all, 122 Africans were thrown overboard.
Yet when the ship owners filed their claim with the insurance company, things went downhill. The insurers disputed the claims of the captain and the owners–largely on the testimony of James Kelsall, First Mate on the Zong. According to the insurance claim, the Africans were thrown overboard “for the safety of the ship,” as there wasn’t enough water for the cargo and crew to survive the rest of the voyage. But Kelsall–who expressed doubts early on to Collingwood about the scheme–testified that there was plenty of water for the remaining leg of the journey. Indeed, when the Zong reached Jamaica on the 22nd of December, there was 422 gallons of drinking water in the hold.
The case went to court, and the court ruled in favor of Collingwood and the owners. During the appeals process, an ex-slave and author, Olaudah Equiano, brought the case–soon to be known as the “Zong Massacre”–to the attention of Granville Sharp, one of Britain’s leading early abolitionists. Sharp immediately became involved in the prosecution of the appeal, even though eminent jurists such as John Lee, Soliciter General for England and Wales, dismissed the affair stating “the case was the same as if horses had been thrown overboard.” This time, the court ruled that the ship owners were not eligible for insurance since the water in the hold proved that the cargo was mismanaged.
Sharp and his colleagues tried to press murder charges against Collingwood and the owners, but to no avail. The Solicitor General, John Lee, stated that:
“What is this claim that human people have been thrown overboard? This is a case of chattels or goods. Blacks are goods and property; it is madness to accuse these well-serving honourable men of murder. They acted out of necessity and in the most appropriate manner for the cause. The late Captain Collingwood acted in the interest of his ship to protect the safety of his crew. To question the judgement of an experienced well-travelled captain held in the highest regard is one of folly, especially when talking of slaves. The case is the same as if wood had been thrown overboard.”
Lee hoped the matter would rest with his decision. Instead it unleashed a firestorm.
Within a few years of the Zong Massacre, abolitionists Thomas Clarkson and James Ramsay issued pamphlets and essays condemning the conditions of the slave trade. Together with Sharp and Equiano, they would approach a young member of Parliament from Yorkshire, William Wilberforce, to take up the cause of abolition.
Beginning in 1784, Wilberforce would lead a 50-year struggle in Parliament to abolish slavery in the British Empire. The efforts of abolitionists such as these led to the 1807 law abolishing the slave trade. 26 years later, the British Parliament outlawed slavery throughout the British Empire. The British abolition movement inspired similar movements worldwide–including a burgeoning anti-slavery movement across the Atlantic that would lead to civil war and eventual emancipation.
And to think…it was all sparked by insurance fraud.
For more information about the Zong Massacre, here are some helpful sites: